Introducing the 2011 AL Rookie of the Year: Jesus Montero

Jesus Montero will win the AL Rookie of the Year. Here's why.

Let's start with Montero himself. He has great career minor league stats. He hit .326 with 34 doubles, 17 homers, 87 RBI, and a .371 OBP in 132 games for Low-A Charleston in '08. He did even better between High-A Tampa and Double-A Trenton in '09, hitting .337 with 25 doubles, 17 homers, 70 RBI, and a .389 OBP in 92 games. Those 2 seasons proved that he was a great prospect. But his 2010 season proved he will be a great major leaguer. His stats on the year were really good for Triple-A Scranton. He hit .289 with 34 doubles, 21 homers, 75 RBI, and a .353 OBP in 123 games. Those look like Montero's usual great stats, but they're differerent. Montero started off very slowly, hitting just .247 with 2 homers in April. But, if you thought that was bad, Montero had possibly the worst month in his pro career in May, hitting just .217 with only 1 homer. Montero was going through a tough stretch- he was facing adversity. And, he got through it. He hit .283 with 3 homers in June, showing flashes of his usual self. Then, he broke out the rest of the year. He hit .342 with 5 homers (and a ridiculous .441 OBP) in July, .330 with 7 homers in August, and .370 with 3 homers in just 6 games in September. Montero is a great player who can overcome adversity at the plate.

Also, Montero has really improved defensively at catcher. He posted a .992 Fld% and threw out a decent 23% of attempted base stealers. It's hard to tell whether he'll ever be a full-time catcher (like Jorge Posada has been the past several years), but he could certainly catch a good 80 or 90 games for the Yankees in '10. Posada could catch most of the others.

Speaking of Posada, he has really declined the past couple of years, as expected by an old catcher. Posada had the best year of his career at age 35 in '07, hitting .337 with 42 doubles, 20 homers, 90 RBI, and an incredible .426 OBP in 144 games. Then in '08, he got hurt, and hit .268 with 3 homers and 22 RBI in just 51 games. But, Posada got right back on track in '09, hitting .285 with 25 doubles, 22 homers, 81 RBI, and a .363 OBP in 111 games. Then, Posada had a bad year in '10, hitting just .248 with 23 doubles, 18 homers, just 57 RBI, and a .357 OBP in 120 games. Don't even get me started defensively, as he has declined from a .994 Fld% and a 24% CS% in '07 to a .986 Fld% and just a 15% CS% in '10. Posada doesn't have much left. His contract is up after the 2011 season, during which he will turn 40. Posada's goodbye to baseball could be as a part-time catcher and DH (still getting 400 at-bats) with Montero being the nearly full-time catcher. Francisco Cervelli would also fit in as a backup catcher when Posada needs a day off.

Cervelli. He's so clutch, but so bad. He hit an OK .271 in '10, but with no homers. No homers! He did hit 11 doubles and 3 triples, drive in 38 runs, and post a .359 OBP in 93 games. He hit .316 with runners in scoring position, getting 25 hits for 37 RBI. He even hit .381 with 24 RBI with 2 outs and runners on scoring position. Where he really did his damage was with the bases loaded. In those situations, he hit .545 with 20 of his RBI. Cervelli was so clutch that he had more hits with runners on (40) than with the bases empty (32). He hit .290 with runners on and .250 with no one on base. He gets clutch hits with runners on base, but in pretty much every other situation he's terrible. Now, let's talk about his defense. He calls a great game and all that, but he was terrible defensively in '10. He posted just a .980 Fld% (worse than Posada!) with just a 14% CS% (also worst than Posada)! He's just bad. He did only allow 2 passed balls, and that is very good. Still, he barely deserves to be in the majors defensively and is just slightly better offensively. He's in no position to take away at-bats from Montero. Maybe he'll catch 30 games in '10.

So, Posada declining, Cervelli performing below the league average, and Montero overcoming adversity and just being great amounts to Montero getting most of the at-bats at catcher. And, since Montero is just such a great hitter, my prediction is that he will win the 2011 AL Rookie of the Year.